Turning a Bad Smell to a Good Aroma

Turning a Bad Smell to a Good Aroma ? Ki Tisa

Rabbi Shmuel Rabinowitz, Rabbi of the Western Wall and Holy Sites
At the beginning of this week?s Torah portion, Ki Tisa, we read a slew of directives given to Moses in preparation for building the Mishkan, the Tabernacle, that temporary temple that accompanied the Jewish nation until the Temple was established in its permanent place in Jerusalem.


Turning a Bad Smell to a Good Aroma

One of the directives pertains to the making of the incense, a blend of herbs and balms placed on coals inside the Mishkan which spread a pleasant smell:


And the Lord said to Moses: “Take for yourself aromatics, [namely] balsam sap, onycha and galbanum, aromatics and pure frankincense; they shall be of equal weight.

And you shall make it into incense? 

and you shall set some of it before the testimony in the Tent of Meeting?it shall be to you a holy of holies. 

(Exodus 30, 34 ? 36)

One of the ingredients in the incense was the galbanum.  Surprisingly, the Babylonian Talmud says that this ingredient actually had a bad smell!  This peculiar detail is related to a fabled story which is no less surprising:

?Rav ?ana bar Bizna says that Rabbi Shimon ?asida says: Any fast that does not include the participation of some of the sinners of the Jewish people is not a fast, as the smell of galbanum is foul and yet the verse lists it with the ingredients of the incense.?


(Babylonian Talmud, Tractate Keritut, page 6)

That foul-smelling ingredient, when mixed with all the other ingredients of the incense, made its smell pleasant. The blending of its smell with other smells combined to form a pleasant aroma. Chazal learned something from this about the complexity of human society and the manner in which society should be conducted.

Many of the negative acts done in our world stem from loneliness, from disconnection, from the emotional distancing between a person and his environment.  There could be trait that in a certain situation can bring about blessings for the world, but if a person is disconnected from society and acts alone, that same trait can become an obstacle and bring about negative behavior.



When man stands before G-d, it is an individual act since each of us is a person unto himself.  But there is also a shared aspect of a society composed of many different kinds of people, some good, some less.  When they unite and stand together before G-d, they create a joint reality which does not exist when each of them stands separately.  The whole is greater than the sum of its parts.

This is how the HaRan (Rabbi Nissim of Gerona, Barcelona, 14th century) explains this in his book Derashot HaRan:

?The message in the galbanum that was placed with the incense and it seemed like it would ruin it because of its bad smell ? and with that the prophecy states that it is not complete without it, so it is when we are joined in our worship of G-d by the sinners and criminals, that our worship is not ruined, but by this it becomes even more complete.

(Derashot Haran)

A healthy society is one that can also contain its less pleasant parts and repair them by properly integrating them.  According to the HaRan, the entire society benefits from this.

The incense spreading a pleasant aroma in the Mishkan represents the entire Jewish nation, with all its varied layers and styles.  Even the ?sinners?, when they are involved and integrated into society, spread a pleasant aroma that honors G-d in the Mishkan.

Today June 14, 2021

End of prayer time:
Mid day:
הכותל המערבי

We invite you to be a true partner and assist in the ongoing maintenance of the Western Wall


Send a Note

Interesting Facts

The Western Wall Plaza hosts approximately 60,000 people. It symbolizes the Jewish link to Jerusalem and serves as the synagogue closest to the remains of both Holy Temples.
The Western Wall's visible stones tell of its history from the time of the Holy Temples' ruin. The original Herodian stones are distinct from the others in size and in their unique borders.
The building style of "grading" used when layering the Western Wall's stones, teaches us that the Temple Mount's walls were not perpendicular but marginally sloping.
פרשת שבוע

Parasha of the Week

Notice for Women's Section in Tunnels

The women's section in the Western Wall Tunnels closes on Fridays at 13:00 and opens again about 15 minutes before Shabbat begins.

Event Calendar

נא בדוק את החיבור שלך לאינטרנט

Skip to content